Menu

It is a common misconception that with prison comes parole, when this is not true.

The State of Washington abolished its parole system in 1984 when the state legislature passed the Sentencing Reform Act (SRA). The SRA was said to “replace” the parole system. However, to “replace” obviously means to swap something for something else. There was no replacement, only eliminating a criminal justice function that allows prisoners to demonstrate growth, rehabilitation, change, and remorse.

Let’s back up.

Why did the State of Washington want to eliminate something that so many states find crucial and necessary for evaluating prisoners’ mental or psychological growth or deterioration, their behavior, and their looming future? Why get rid of such a valuable tool? Is it so expensive to operate compared to incarceration, or what?

The State of Washington provided four reasons for abolishing parole back in 1984, and they are:

  1. Sentencing Uniformity. Washington State claimed that the parole system often resulted in inconsistent outcomes, with different prisoners serving sentences of different durations for similar crimes.
  2. Accountability. Determinate (versus indeterminate) sentencing was intended to hold prisoners more accountable by requiring them to serve a precise quantity of their sentence without any possibility of early release through parole.
  3. Transparency. Determinate sentencing allegedly provides victims, prisoners, and the public with a clear understanding of exactly how long a prisoner will remain incarcerated.
  4. Perceived Leniency of Parole. Critics of parole argued that it allowed some prisoners the ability to serve shorter sentences than the public or victims expected, undermining confidence in the criminal justice system.

Without parole, prisoners in Washington State have two remaining avenues available to them for reducing sentences. There are so-called, “time off for good behavior,” and pleas to the Washington State Governor for clemency or a pardon.

For more than 99% of all Washington State prisoners, the only possible method to reduce their sentences – regardless of what growth, change, or accomplishments they display – is “good behavior” time, and this reduction is strictly limited. While prisoners incarcerated for non-violent crimes may receive up to one-third off their sentence for good behavior, and that tenth may only begin tolling once they have served out any mandatory minimum sentence and any enhancements (for instance, weapon or gang enhancements to their sentence). Even this figure is somewhat misleading. A glance at the average duration of a prison sentence in Washington demonstrates that a prisoner who receives all available good times will serve only a slightly longer average sentence than prisoners in other states for the same crime. In other words, “good behavior” time is not so much dedicated from the sentences of Washington state prisoners for actual good behavior, but rather just an average sentence (regardless of behavior) that Washington State prisoners may take away from prisoners who refuse to work mandatory jobs, etc.

Washington has been operating under the SRA for 40 years now, and it is past time to examine if it has accomplished what it originally set out to do. The first cited reason for the SRA was sentencing uniformity or ensuring that individuals served similar sentences for similar crimes. A simple look at criminal sentences from even the last 15 years shows that the SRA has failed in its alleged goal of uniformity.

One homicide case in King County from 2009 featured four co-defendants all charged with the same crime and all four received different sentences. One gunman received a 15-year sentence, another a 20-year sentence, while one accomplice received just under 6 years, and another accomplice received 32 years. Countless other cases, even from the last months of 2024 demonstrate similar instances of wildly divergent sentences, clearly revealing the fact: The SRA has created no uniformity in sentencing.

The second stated goal of the SRA was Accountability.

The word, accountable, means answerable or responsible. So, if a defendant in a criminal case is sentenced to a shorter sentence than some other defendant, does that make the first defendant less accountable? Most of us understand that being accountable is simply taking ownership of our actions: What am I responsible for?

So, in our criminal justice system, admitting all guilt (and therefore taking all accountability) without a plea bargain agreement, usually results in the longest possible sentence for a criminal defendant, in general. The prosecution and judge will take all confessions, all apologies to the victim, and all personal accountability and simply heap more changes on a defendant. Do these additional years in prison, at public expense, increase accountability for the defendant who has taken full responsibility? It is not clear that the length of a sentence equates to accountability but instead equates to wise legal strategy or its lack.

What is accountability without real ownership of one’s action?

Next, let’s look at the third claim of the SRA: Transparency.

A defendant’s sentence is public knowledge, now easily accessible via the internet regardless of which county they received their conviction in. In those other states aside from Washington, which broadly employ the tool of parole, parties involved with the case are notified of any upcoming parole hearings and are given a chance to provide input. The same is true of clemency and commutation hearings in other states and Washington; and if some incarcerated person is resentenced and soon to be released, the court notifies all involved parties before that prisoners may be released from custody.

In states that utilize parole, defendants receive sentences such as “25-to-life”, for example. That means that they will be eligible for parole after serving 25 years. If they are never granted parole, they will then serve the rest of their lives in prison. Looking at a more common sentence range of 8-12 years, there is no hiding the reality that within the last 4 years of said sentence, that individual may be granted parole and released back to society before the entire maximum sentence was served. Full transparency is provided at every stage of the process.

The SRA argued that it would repair the public image of leniency caused by parole, but is the parole system inherently lenient?

It seems that leniency depends upon actual individuals serving on a parole board, more so than the ideal of parole itself, and the perception of leniency is extremely subjective. To some Americans, they would prefer to see a fellow citizen who is convicted of a serious crime remain in prison until that person dies, and anything less than that will be considered leniency. Perhaps if those Americans who felt so strongly about keeping people locked up forever realized the expense of keeping someone in prisons or paid that cost out of their pocket (which they unknowingly do through their taxes) they would be more eager to find worthy candidates for early release.

That brings us to the issue of cost, and the ugly truth we rarely hear much about.

In Washington State, the Department of Corrections Budget Office figures reveal that in 2022, those incarcerated in Washington’s prisons cost the taxpayers between $117 and $297 per day, depending upon which prison the prisoners were housed within. While that equals an average of $75,000 per year per prisoner, the taxpayer would be wise to understand that those with life sentences or very long sentences are considered higher-risk prisoners and are therefore housed in higher security (more expensive) prisons, which cost more than $100,000 per year ($297 per day) per prisoner. With 13,714 prisoners locked in Washington State’s prisons last year, and the prices of everything increasing as we all see, it’s safe to say that the 2025 figures will easily exceed $1 billion per year.

Unlike most other states that use parole for vetting prisoners that might be safely released into the community, Washington State’s lack of parole will continually create higher and higher costs as prisoners age, requiring ever-increasing medical care. The budgetary domino effect of DOC’s massive expense impacts every other part of the state budget process as funds must be reallocated from other areas to cover the ever-growing costs of incarcerating an aging population.

Another negative of Washington State’s lack of parole is an actual reduction in rehabilitation efforts. Those prisoners with very long sentences are often denied the ability to participate in various education and rehabilitation programs, as these are focused upon those with shorter sentences first.

Would reinstating parole in Washington State be expensive?

It is difficult to say, and certainly, that various elements in the Washington State bureaucracy (who appear to oppose a return of parole) claim questionable astronomical cost projections for a parole system. However, the Federal parole system (nationwide) operated on a budget of $14.6 million in 2023. In the 2020-2021 fiscal year, Colorado’s parole board (which is comparable to Washington) operated on a budget of only $2.44 million. Despite the claims of such great expense associated with parole, only 9 states, including Washington, do not utilize the tool of parole. It hardly seems likely that 41 states can implement parole cost-effectively, and Washington State cannot.

Is it possible that there are hidden costs from 40 years of eliminating the tool of parole from the criminal justice system of Washington State?

Parole gives prisoners an incentive to pursue positive programming, education, and personal growth. Regardless of the sentence length for a prisoner, as citizens, do we want these prisoners to educate themselves, and work on themselves, including such things as anger management and other proactive social/cognitive behavioral programs? After all, 95% of those incarcerated will be released one day.

Or do we want to keep locking them up with no incentive, little opportunity to improve themselves, and little reason to try? That only perpetuates the same behavior that landed them in prison to begin with. Most anyone can understand that we are all motivated by both “carrot and stick” and Washington State has removed the carrot that incentivized the incarcerated to seek the very best use of their incarcerated time so they can find the key to succeed in society.

Citizens and lawmakers in the State of Washington are beginning to understand something has not worked well, and something must change. Why Washington State has strayed so far from the practices of the other West Coast states of California and Oregon remains a puzzle. In the last year or so, some voices within the Washington State Department of Corrections began researching the “Norway Model” in an initiative called “The Washington Way” which aims to normalize or humanize incarceration conditions. These same elements within the bureaucracy have sponsored legislation to increase the quantity of good time that prisoners can earn while incarcerated, but as most states have realized the real answer to incentivizing good behavior is parole. For instance, in Wisconsin, which enjoys relatively low crime rates, even a prisoner with a life sentence may be eligible for parole after serving approximately 14 years, which compares to Norway and other European countries that consider a life sentence to be 15 years.

Crime in Washington State has been embarrassingly and needlessly high and the efforts to improve the situation seem counterintuitive at best. Instead of tolerating constant repeat “non-violent” offenders, allowing them to run wild, while a one-time violent offense results in 20 or 30 years in prison, the system must return to a basis of balance and merit. There have seemingly been no mitigating impulses for an anomalous violent offender featuring a statistical recidivism rate very near zero, whereas a repeat property crime offender’s recidivism rate hovers above 70 percent. The defendant who almost certainly would never re-offend spends decades in prison, consuming taxpayer resources, while the repeat offender seems to get away with almost no accountability at all.

The system is also filled with mental health and addiction cases that could arguably be better served in a mental hospital or treatment center, but the funds continue to flow to prison instead.

The choices that need to be made seem to be obvious. They just must be made, and soon.

No Comments

    Leave a Reply